Compare
A CraftingStore alternative, compared honestly
CraftingStore and Minecraftstore.io both pay you into your own account. The difference is how they earn: CraftingStore with monthly plans and no cut, we with a fee per sale and everything included.
The two side by side
As CraftingStore describes it on its own site and help pages, checked in October 2026. Check theirs before you decide.
Minecraftstore.io
|
CraftingStore | |
|---|---|---|
| Fee per sale | 5% per sale, minimum €0.25 | None |
| Monthly plan | None needed for any feature to sell. Optional Pro at €9.99 for more themes, your own CSS and your whole team | Bronze free. Silver €8.99 a month for HTTPS on your own domain, subscriptions, banning players and removing their branding. Gold €12.99, Platinum €19.99 |
| Payment costs | Stripe's own rate, passed on exactly | Your own payment provider's rate |
| Where the money goes | Your own Stripe account | Your own PayPal, Stripe or Mollie account |
| Payouts set up | In the dashboard, Stripe asks what it needs | You open and keep your own gateway accounts |
| Your own domain | On every store, with HTTPS | Yes, with HTTPS from Silver |
| A website for your server | Home, news, staff and vote pages, free | Custom pages on a paid plan |
| Banning players | On every store | From Silver |
| Sales tax and chargebacks | Yours, as the seller | Yours, as the seller |
Everything included, from the first sale
-
Discord roles
A free bot gives buyers their role and takes it back when a timed rank ends.
-
Timed ranks
Sell VIP for 30 days, with expiry commands and a reminder mail before the end.
-
An in-game /buy menu
A chest menu with your products, and a checkout link with the player's name filled in.
-
Themes and modules
Recent payments, top buyer, a monthly goal and your Discord, in your colours.
-
Your own domain
With HTTPS, on every store.
-
A person to talk to
Support from the person who built it, who runs a server too.
When CraftingStore is the better choice
If your server sells a lot every month and you are happy with a monthly plan, no cut at all is hard to beat, and CraftingStore also supports Rust. If you would rather pay nothing until you sell, with every feature included and payouts set up in one place, Minecraftstore.io is built for that.
Questions
Is CraftingStore cheaper than Minecraftstore.io?
Per sale, yes: CraftingStore takes no cut, so you only pay your payment provider. It earns from monthly plans: Silver, at €8.99 a month, is the one with HTTPS on your own domain and subscriptions. For a store that sells less than about €180 a month, no plan and our fee cost less than Silver.
Can I move from CraftingStore?
Yes. There is no import from CraftingStore yet, so you add your products by hand, then connect Stripe and install our plugin. Ask us and we help you move.
Who handles sales tax?
With both, you do: the money goes to your own account, so the sale is yours.
Read next
Your players are already asking for a rank.
Give them a place to buy it. Your store is live in minutes, and it costs nothing until the first sale.